Diversity in Young Adult and Middle Grade
YA and MG books about diverse characters and/or written by diverse authors. Not limited to, but includes: Disability, Ethnicity, Race, GLBT.
Like
Lists are re-scored approximately every 5 minutes.
Emilia
3207 books
175 friends
175 friends
Tamora
2811 books
4884 friends
4884 friends
Michael
467 books
194 friends
194 friends
Kayleigh
1859 books
47 friends
47 friends
Elisquared
6730 books
439 friends
439 friends
Ronni
705 books
36 friends
36 friends
Julia
5638 books
167 friends
167 friends
Polenth
607 books
356 friends
356 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Lark of The Bookwyrm's Hoard
(new)
May 03, 2014 11:58AM
I love The Horse and His Boy, but I don't know that it belongs on this list. None of the Calormene characters are portrayed positively, with the notable exception of Aravis. Given that Calormen and its religion are clearly intended to evoke historically Muslim nations such as Persia, the anti-Calormene bias is troubling (though perhaps understandable in historical context.)
reply
|
flag
The Bookwyrm's Hoard wrote: "I love The Horse and His Boy, but I don't know that it belongs on this list. None of the Calormene characters are portrayed positively, with the notable exception of Aravis. Given that Calormen and..."
Hey! I created the list, but once I released it out into the wild, I no longer have control of who votes for what. But of course, I like a discussion in the comments!
Hey! I created the list, but once I released it out into the wild, I no longer have control of who votes for what. But of course, I like a discussion in the comments!
Oh, I wasn't directing my comment at any particular person! And I really appreciate the list -- #WeNeedDiverseBooks for a whole lot of reasons!
Emilia, I also think this is an essential list and thank you for starting it. However, like you pointed out, I've heard other bibliophiles who started particular lists say that people put books on the list that have nothing to do with the heading info. Yet they not only have no control over erroneous books added to the list, but they have no recourse to get those erroneous books removed. I would hope people would be smart enough to know which books are and which are not representative of diversity on this list. btw, there is another list titled "POC main characters" someone started before Debby's #weneeddiversebooks campaign that narrows down the criteria considerably. Maybe someone could do that where they have one GLBT list and one (fill in the blank) list, etc., separating them more distinctly.
I'm a Goodreads librarian - I removed some books that I know for sure do not meet the criteria of this list:
- Harry Potter series
- Chronicles of Narnia series
- Percy Jackson series
- Books that are not YA or middle-grade, like The Kite Runner and To Kill a Mockingbird
There are some I'm not sure fit, but I haven't read them - the top-rated book, for example. The only diverse content I can see from the description is that the main character cross-dresses, but that's more in a "need to pretend to be a boy for practical reasons" than "my gender identity is male," from what I can gather. But I've left it in case I'm wrong.
- Harry Potter series
- Chronicles of Narnia series
- Percy Jackson series
- Books that are not YA or middle-grade, like The Kite Runner and To Kill a Mockingbird
There are some I'm not sure fit, but I haven't read them - the top-rated book, for example. The only diverse content I can see from the description is that the main character cross-dresses, but that's more in a "need to pretend to be a boy for practical reasons" than "my gender identity is male," from what I can gather. But I've left it in case I'm wrong.
How is the Hunger Games series a part of this list? It has three minor (emphasis on minor) characters of color. BTW, those characters all die before book 3! Please remove the Hunger Games series from this list.
The Doomsday Kids series by Karyn Folan deserves a high place in any list such as this. The books in this amazing YA series are the richest in diversity that I have ever read.
Not only in terms of ethnic background but there are strong characters with disability, homosexual characters and overweight characters that are all great examples of how to write an excellent cast outside of the expected, boring cliches. I highly recommend this series.
http://thedoomsdaykids.com/wp/
Not only in terms of ethnic background but there are strong characters with disability, homosexual characters and overweight characters that are all great examples of how to write an excellent cast outside of the expected, boring cliches. I highly recommend this series.
http://thedoomsdaykids.com/wp/
Kate wrote: "I'm a Goodreads librarian - I removed some books that I know for sure do not meet the criteria of this list:
- Harry Potter series
- Chronicles of Narnia series
- Percy Jackson series
- Books that..."
Why wouldn't the Percy Jackson books fit? Many of the main characters in the series have ADHD and dyslexia.
- Harry Potter series
- Chronicles of Narnia series
- Percy Jackson series
- Books that..."
Why wouldn't the Percy Jackson books fit? Many of the main characters in the series have ADHD and dyslexia.
I would like to nominate my book Ethan's Secret for this list. It deals with sexual development, and also touches on teen homosexuality.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...
Mrs. Bernet wrote: "How is the Hunger Games series a part of this list? It has three minor (emphasis on minor) characters of color. BTW, those characters all die before book 3! Please remove the Hunger Games series fr..."
Katniss ethnicity isn't white. It doesn't matter if the sister is blond, the father was POC and so is katniss.
Katniss ethnicity isn't white. It doesn't matter if the sister is blond, the father was POC and so is katniss.
Karen wrote: "Mrs. Bernet wrote: "How is the Hunger Games series a part of this list? It has three minor (emphasis on minor) characters of color. BTW, those characters all die before book 3! Please remove the Hu..."
What race was Katniss's father, and where do we learn this in the books?
What race was Katniss's father, and where do we learn this in the books?
Shadowjac wrote: "Karen wrote: "Mrs. Bernet wrote: "How is the Hunger Games series a part of this list? It has three minor (emphasis on minor) characters of color. BTW, those characters all die before book 3! Please..."
The book doesn't mention race but mentions that most people of district 12 including Katniss Gale and Katniss father had dark skin or olive therefore POC. They aren't tanned. Question for you: Does the book mention Katniss being white? The sister is blond but Katniss resembles her dad.
The book doesn't mention race but mentions that most people of district 12 including Katniss Gale and Katniss father had dark skin or olive therefore POC. They aren't tanned. Question for you: Does the book mention Katniss being white? The sister is blond but Katniss resembles her dad.
I wonder why they made Katniss white in the movies, is that how the author saw her? Right now she doesn't seem to fit to me.
Does the future sees women of color looking more white than any other race?
I just have a problem seeing has anything but white. the author should have stood up to movie exec. about casting the characters the way they truly are.
no offense meant, just my humble opinion.
Does the future sees women of color looking more white than any other race?
I just have a problem seeing has anything but white. the author should have stood up to movie exec. about casting the characters the way they truly are.
no offense meant, just my humble opinion.
Emotonal wrote: "I wonder why they made Katniss white in the movies, is that how the author saw her? Right now she doesn't seem to fit to me.
Does the future sees women of color looking more white than any other r..."
Whitewashing is common in movies. Also, not exactly whitewashing, but Anabeth from Percy Jackson isn't blonde or 12 years old in the movie. Movies never get it right.
Does the future sees women of color looking more white than any other r..."
Whitewashing is common in movies. Also, not exactly whitewashing, but Anabeth from Percy Jackson isn't blonde or 12 years old in the movie. Movies never get it right.
Emotonal wrote: "I wonder why they made Katniss white in the movies, is that how the author saw her? Right now she doesn't seem to fit to me.
Does the future sees women of color looking more white than any other r..."
It's called white-washing.
Does the future sees women of color looking more white than any other r..."
It's called white-washing.
Island of the Blue Dolphins (Island of the Blue Dolphins, #1)
While it's technically true that there is a Native American main character, this book is pretty inaccurate and problematic. Should it really be on this list?
While it's technically true that there is a Native American main character, this book is pretty inaccurate and problematic. Should it really be on this list?
@connie: unfortunately, this list is simply for listing diverse YA/MG books. it is not a list of 'good' diverse stories (etc) so I cannot take it off the list (it'd be against policy since it technically fits the criteria). But that sort of commentary is perfect for your personal review space. thanks for bringing it to our attention.
There is a lot wrong with these comments I don't mean to be rude but as for Percy Jackson like some earlier said a lot of the kids have ADHD or Dyslexia. For Hungar Games how often do you see a female heroine in books or a female leader Katniss is both I personally see that as diversity well yes now you see more female main characters but most of the time from what I have read they either get overshadowed by the male leads or they are witches type things which means that the female part is kinda forced on you only read or see female witches. Again I don't want to make waves and these are my ideals. I just find this a little upsetting.
Related News
Need another excuse to treat yourself to a new book this week? We've got you covered with the buzziest new releases of the day, according to early...
Anyone can add books to this list.