Review Highlights
“All of us have always talked about the best eats on Arthur Ave from bread, pasta, mozzarella, to sausage.” in 9 reviews
“I highly recommend their proscuitto, pesto sauce, and their large canister of Edda extra virgin olive oil.” in 3 reviews
“Always used to by the amazing olive oil by the gallon and give it as a gift to family.” in 13 reviews
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Beer, Wine & Spirits
in Butcher, Meat Shops
Amenities and More
About the Business
Teitel Brothers is the oldest Italian specialty store on Arthur Avenue since 1915! We are stocked with the best imported & domestic cheese, deli meats, oils, tomatoes, pasta, dried beans, spices, tuna, anchovies, olives, and dessert items like panettone. The list goes on and on! We are known for providing the best and most unique experience for our customers. Aside from the best quality products, our customers rave about their experiences at Teitel They start as customers and soon become family! Don't wait any longer, come on in and join the Teitel Brothers family...
Ask the Community
Q:
Do they have halva cut to order?
A:
Hi there! Yes we do have halva cut to order. We have marble, pistachio and plain. Thanks!
Edward T., Business Owner3 years ago 2 people found this helpful
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
101 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Noemi M.Berkeley, CA11844216318Dec 31, 2023
Teitel Brothers, run by the Italian brothers, is a true culinary treasure that caters to generations of Italians and food enthusiasts alike. Their selection is nothing short of remarkable, offering a wide array of delectable items to satisfy your every craving.
From cold cuts to the heavenly Prosciutto di Parma, their offerings are a testament to authentic Italian flavors that you won't find elsewhere. The freshness and quality of their products, including the mouthwatering fresh mozzarella and diverse selection of olives, are second to none.
What truly sets Teitel Brothers apart is their commitment to homemade excellence. Their house-made products, such as the incredible soppressata and irresistible salami, are a testament to generations of culinary expertise. And let's not forget the pasta and tomato sauce, which are sure to transport you to the heart of Italy with every bite.
Teitel Brothers is a culinary haven for those who appreciate the richness of Italian cuisine. With a legacy of serving the community for generations, they provide an unparalleled experience, offering a tantalizing array of flavors and authentic products. If you have a passion for Italian food, Teitel Brothers is an absolute must-visit destination that promises to delight your taste buds. It's my first stop when I visit I can't go anywhere until I get my inventory fully stocked, meet you here because you must visit!!!!Helpful 15Thanks 2Love this 20Oh no 0 - Joan G.Dover, NH01Apr 2, 2024
What an incredible find!!! We stepped into another world after visiting the Botanical Gardens. The array of specialty foods was dazzling. When we asked about some meats and cheeses to take home we were treated like royal guests. We were given tasted of prosciutto wrapped around freshly made ricotta drizzled with the best tasting balsamic vinegar ever. It was like taking a private food tour of Little Italy. The quality was superb and the cost was reasonable but the bast was the ambiance. Don't miss a visit to this store that has been in business for over one hundred years!!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Sep 1, 2023
This is the 4th generation here and I can't walk past without getting fresh olives, artichokes & cheese. Staff is fast, friendly, everything is fresh and very delicious. I can't find Italian delicacies like this at home & they don't ship, but they should!
Helpful 14Thanks 2Love this 14Oh no 0 - Jennifer R.New York, NY783321120Nov 19, 2023
Amazing Italian grocer in The Bronx steeped in history and offering a wide array of imported Italian goods. Their staff is always helpful and extremely knowledgeable. The family-run shop may be small, but it's packed with goods and offers everything you could possibly need from pasta to cured meats, cheeses, olives and olive oil, and a lot more. A definite must if you're in the neighborhood or looking for authentic Italian foods.
Helpful 2Thanks 1Love this 1Oh no 0 - Abby R.Tarrytown, NY51Nov 30, 2023
Just left Teitel brothers with the best quality cold cuts and cheese in the area! No one slices the cold cuts like Mike!
He is always happy and welcoming!!!Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 1Oh no 0 - Alan O.New York, NY0102Nov 12, 2023
There's deli and then there's Teitel Brothers Deli. Fresh, amazing and family neighborhood oriented! Usually a line but can you blame them? The best!
Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 1Oh no 0 - Olive O.Brooklyn, NY161831Aug 4, 2023
This is the place. Go in there and buy everything you see. Happiness and that Parmesan cheese with the truffles and the regular Parmesan and ham, they know just how to slice it. God bless you guys. Best food in the world.
Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 1Oh no 0 - Oct 20, 2022
4++ An absolute landmark of Belmont, Little Italy in the BX and Arthur Ave, the generations of the family running Teitel Bros. stay true to their mission of providing high quality Italian deli food and imports. These people love food, and for shoppers who can get past the lack of esthetics at this location, the place is jam packed with the same items you'd find in a supermarket in Italy. Of course go for the imported cheese, cured meats, olives and other delicacies. But don't overlook the San Marzano tomatoes, artisan pastas, cookies, confections and olive oil. No matter how crowded this little corner store gets, for the authenticity, quality and price it cannot be beat - any trip is worthwhile.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Business owner information
Edward T.
Oct 31, 2022
Thank you Kathy!
- Frank S.San Francisco, CA01Oct 11, 2023
Nice place great food. It helps if you are from the neighborhood and they know you so they don't charge you more money than they do the regulars. Born and raised in New York, now live in PA. I travel in 3 or 4 times a year to pick up all my goodies and I always get price ripped off there.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 2 - Mar 8, 2021
I've been shopping here for many decades and never thought to review it.
This is the place to go for all your specialty foods. There's everything from perfect salt cod (bacalao), cheeses to salsiccia.
The staff is very helpful and gracious.
The corner where the entrance is always has a display of canned goods. It's like a lighthouse.Helpful 4Thanks 1Love this 2Oh no 1
You Might Also Consider
in Bakeries
in Pizza, Grocery, Sandwiches