A few weeks ago, I was sitting on my bed with a friend, watching a YouTube video of a man tying the knot of tefillin shel yad in the Sephardi style. She had just bought tefillin and wanted to put them on in her family’s Moroccan tradition, but they had been made for Ashkenazim and didn’t wrap the right way. We had no idea how to tie tefillin, so we found the YouTube video and watched it slowly, pausing every few seconds to make sure our knot matched his.
Avital Morris |
But it still feels feels sad and wrong to learn these skills from the Internet, useful as it is. Ritual practice has centuries of mimetic tradition behind it, and I’ve heard so much about people learning Torah from years in a beit midrash, learning to daven by singing with a chazan, and learning ritual from parents and teachers. Learning from a person who has no idea I exist (and would be horrified if he did) seems like a rupture in this tradition.
I’ve been putting on tefillin since I was twelve, but in the past couple years, I’ve become more serious and more public about it. Since then, several women interested in putting on tefillin have reached out to me for help. Each had tried to figure it out from YouTube and had been thrown off by some combination of the technical complexity, the fact that most of the videos are of extremely burly Chabad men and therefore hard for people who don’t look like that to follow, and the fact that it’s hard, weird, and lonely.
Teaching other women to put on tefillin is one of the most meaningful experiences I’ve had with mitzvot. Tefillin are physically challenging at first: it’s hard to make them tight enough to stay on but loose enough for comfort, and it’s easy to be discouraged and tempted to give up before it becomes second nature. Especially for women who’ve been told that they should not be wearing tefillin, physical difficulty can feel like confirmation that this mitzvah is inaccessible to them. And even years into putting on tefillin, I feel much safer and able to daven when I’m not the only woman in tefillin, so I’m incredibly happy to talk other women through it and say amen to their shehechianu the first time they fulfill this mitzvah. I love the feeling of passing on mitzvot, and I’m happy to have them learn from me instead of the Chabad man on YouTube.
Of course, the tradition is not supposed to work this way. Most boys learn to put on tefillin from their fathers, not their friends. All of the women I’ve helped with tefillin are at least my age and, in the ordinary tradition of tefillin, would have had them for years. We’re turning a vertical tradition, passed from one generation to the next, into a horizontal one, passed within a single generation, and sometimes it feels confused and off-balance.
Halakhic egalitarian Jews have an analogous relationship to mimetic Judaism more generally. Because we think that paradigms of the roles different people play in halaka have shifted completely since the Rabbinic period and most contemporary halakhic authorities do not, we can’t consult most rabbis about many of our questions and end up looking to older sources and trying to map normative halakha to the world we live in.
Although this frontier is sometimes exciting, I will admit to an occasional longing for an Artscroll-type series that would just tell me what to do, instead of the broad collection of sources and opinions that I usually end up with when I need to make any kind of halakhic decision. Our institutions, rituals, and communities use categories that have been understood by Jews for centuries, but the process of figuring out what exactly they look like is still very much ongoing, and is being done largely from the ground up, by people who are not halakhic authorities in any way.
By creating these communities, I hope we are constructing a chain of transmission that, a generation from now, will feel like it’s always been there. I hope that our children will have an experience of this mitzvah that feels like any other Jewish ritual that children see modelled at home, but that can only happen if people know how to put on tefillin in the first place. For now, teaching women to put on tefillin feels like at least a taste of the mimetic tradition by which people have passed on mitzvot for centuries, and I’m proud to be a part of it.
Avital Morris is an alumna of Midreshet Ein Hanatziv and is currently a second-year at the University of Chicago.