Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Abstract:- This qualitative-conversational analysis study That male and female have different conversational styles
aimed to analyze the conversational styles based on which may affect their performance in their language
gender through the responses of the participants on a subjects.
given specific topic. It also aimed to examine the
significant difference of the students’ way of answering In Malaysia, researchers Majzub and Rais (2010) argue
when analyzed according to gender. Further, it aimed to that male underachievement is a topic of critical importance
elucidate why gender affects how they deliver their in their country and around the world. In their research, they
thoughts through a conversation. This study is anchored found that girls were outperforming boys in almost all
to the theory of “Genderlect” popularized by Deborah subject domains whether they were science or non-science
Tannen (1984), who proposes that there is a difference in majors. Majzub and Rais (2010) also pointed out that the
language based on gender. She emphasized the existence situation worsened as students progressed through the
of two major types of conversational styles. That shapes different levels of education with eventual tertiary level
the communicative behavior of individual speakers: a matriculation reflecting a 65–35% enrollment of females
high-involvement style and the opposing high- relative to males.
considerateness style. These styles can reflect the general
linguistic behavior of women and men in conversation. In the Philippines, Tamayo (2014) cited on his research
She also added that there are linguistic features which paper, that boys are encouraged to concentrate on the
were developed by men and women during conversation. sciences and mathematics while girls are expected to be
Following the suggestive range of entries from Clark and more knowledgeable on languages and the arts. This simply
Braun (2013) which is 10-100 participants, this study was shows that gender has an effect on how a male and female
process their thought that may cause male students to have
solely focused in gathering data from forty (40) students,
low grades in language subjects and worst is to drop the
comprising twenty (20) male and twenty (20) female,
specifically from the Senior High School, Grade 11. As to subject. With this, it is evident that there are problems in
the participants’ responses there were six (6) treating males’ and females’ responses with their language
communicative behavior observed during the talk show performance.
production namely: speed; preference on topic/ In my class, whenever I give students impromptu
argument; turn takings; directness; emotion/intimacy; activities such as oral recitations and essays, the girls are
establishment of authority and strategy. With regards to observed to have more ideas to share compared to the boys
the six (6) linguistic features formed into themes that can be seen in the essays that my students submitted and
emerged that women ask more questions than men; even during oral recitations. In writing their papers, the girls
women use more fillers than men; both men and women have more personal content basing it from their experiences,
use intensifiers for emphasis; women use more rebuttals because they are more open and expressive as compared to
compared to affirmatives than men, women use more the boys. Boys, on the other hand, are observed to be more
adjectives than men. The results are believed to be factual and are usually timid. These factors were observed to
significant for the language teachers, for it is important have affected the grades that my students received since I
to know the different conversational styles of our assessed my students on the contents of their written and
students most especially that gender is one of the factors oral outputs.
to be considered in the speech delivery of our students.
On the other hand, in Tagum Division, I have not
Keywords:- Education, genderlect, qualitative- found any study yet about conversational analysis which
conversational analysis, Tagum City, Philippines. focuses on gender. In this study, I used the classroom-based
Talk Show production to gather the data from the
I. INTRODUCTION participants. I have seen the urgency to understand and
Men and women are two different individuals who analyze the conversational styles based on gender through
have diverse personality which gives them unique traits. the responses of the participants on a given specific topic.
This causes them to have dissimilar responses to the topics Moreover, I have found the need to conduct this study
that are given to them. This is why we can observe men and because as a language teacher, one of its prerequisites is to
women communicating very differently from one another.
These usual situations have encouraged me to carry out Further, people who have high-involvement
a study that would show understanding and will let me conversational style (rapport talk) tend to speak faster which
analyze the Conversational Styles based on gender wherein can be classified in speed in speech, overlap or launch other
this is considered very significant in the field of teaching people’s speech or turn-taking, prefer personal topic and
English and Oral Communication subject. story-telling. Also, different childhood experiences of boys
and girls affects and causes misunderstanding later on in
A. Purpose of the Study their relationships during adulthood. She stated that during
The purpose of this conversational analysis was to conversations, women use indirectness than direct speech,
analyze the different responses of gender based on make less jokes, and it is highly observable that they reflect
conversational styles in a classroom-based talk show emotions and are more concerned with intimacy (Tannen,
production. It also aimed to examine the significant 1990 as cited by Erkaya, 2018).
difference of the students’ way of answering when analyzed
according to gender. Further, it aimed to elucidate why On the other hand, people who have high-
gender affects how they deliver their thoughts through a considerateness conversational style (report talk) have the
conversation. opposite characteristics than high-involvement style,
meaning, they tend to speak slower, wait for its turn to
B. Research Questions speak, and avoids personal stories. Men are more
This study specifically sought answers to the following straightforward during conversations which mean that they
questions: are direct in their speech, make more jokes and are more
1) What are the conversational styles present in the concerned with establishing their status or authority
classroom-based Talk Show production of the male (Tannen, 1990 as cited by Erkaya, 2018).
and female students in terms of Communicative
Behavior? In context of the study, the classroom-based talk show
2) What are the linguistic features found in the production raw transcript was analyzed as to the existence of
conversation of male and female students in the two major types of conversational styles as presented by
classroom-based Talk Show production? Tannen (1990) of which for better and easier understanding,
3) How does gender affect the conversational styles in I enumerated conversational features which summed up the
classroom-based Talk Show production? two major styles namely: (1) speed, (2) preference on topic
or argument, (3) turn-takings, (4) directness, (5)
C. Theoretical Lens emotion/intimacy, and (6) establishment of authority and
This study is gleaned through the theory of strategy. Also, this transcript was further analyzed as to the
“Genderlect” popularized by Deborah Tannen (1990) which occurrence of the six linguistic features found in the
proposed that there is a difference in language based on conversations of both genders namely: (1) question, (2)
gender. This theory fundamentally explained that the fillers, (3) hedges, (4) intensifiers, (5) affirmatives and last
process of gender acculturation further develops the is the (6) adjectives.
different linguistic features used by men and women
speakers and how these features become identity markers D. Scope and Limitation of the Study
for men or women in their social context. In addition, these This study is delimited on understanding and analyzing
linguistic features have been enumerated in details by the different responses of students based on their gender,
Lakoff (1977) which includes the questions (tag questions which is selected and highly recommended of the advisers
and WH-questions), fillers, hedges, intensifiers, affirmatives or English teachers from Division of Tagum, School Year
and adjectives. 2019-2020. This study was conducted within the months of
November 2019 to February 2020.
In connection with this theory, Tannen (1990) further
explained and elucidated that the amount of talk contributed Following the suggestive range of entries from Clark
by women and men differ in public, contexts, formal or and Braun (2013) which is 10-100 participants, this study
private, and last is intimate context. She further elucidated solely focused in gathering data from forty (40) students,
those men tend to value public, referentially orientated talk, comprising twenty (20) male and twenty (20) female, there
while women value and enjoy intimate, affective orientated are one moderator for each production and twelve students
talk. Further, each gender contributed more in the situation for the production team, specifically from the Senior High
in which they are most comfortable. However, Tannen School, Grade 11. The topics provided for each group were
pointed out that these conversational styles may be affected the foundation of their discussions. Other irrelevant answers
by the speech linguistic features of each gender. Yet, she provided by the students were not considered in the analysis
explained that men appeared to regard public formal of this study.
contexts as opportunities for display, while they are more
reserved in private interaction which can be attributed those E. Importance of the Study
men are highly considerate speakers. On the other hand, I believe that the results of this study would be beneficial
women appeared to take more account of their receivers’ in providing valuable information to the following
individuals who would probably get affected in most of the
This study will also help the School Administrators to Chapter 3 describes the application or usage of
give action towards the diverse activities for genders. These qualitative research methodology, and articulates the data
activities will be an avenue for them to express themselves. collection, data analysis and issues associated with
participants’ confidentiality. The chapter addresses
The DepEd officials will further understand the information related to research design appropriateness, the
perceptions of students based on the given topic or situation. study population and selection, and data collection
This will also allow them decide what are the various approaches.
activities that they can offer for the students that focuses on
gender. Chapter 4 discloses the results of the classroom-based
Talk Show Production which contains tables and analysis of
Lastly, to the future researchers who want to conduct a data referring to the research questions.
study related to this inquiry. This will provide supporting
data that they will need for their future research. Language Chapter 5 discusses the major themes extracted from
and gender can be considered a very good study, especially the results coming from the participants’ ideas with
that it has significance in learning English. supporting statements coming from the various authors. It is
in this chapter that conclusions of the study, as well as its
F. Definition of Terms implications are cited.
The following terms are defined both conceptually and
operationally for further understanding about the study. II. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
a) Conversational Analysis. This chapter presents the following studies, articles,
It is defined as an approach to the study of social concepts, and citations which are the supporting related facts
interaction and talk-in-interaction that, although rooted in that will give an insight about the understanding and
the sociological study of everyday life, has exerted analysis of the conversational styles among gender.
significant influence across the humanities and social
sciences including linguistics (Sidnell, 2016). In this study, A. Genderlect
this term refers to the method used on analyzing the The study in the matter of gender distinction in
gathered data. language is broad and ancient. Given the extensive topics
offered for analysis by this study, linguists come up with
b) Classroom-based Talk Show new hypothesis constantly. It is said that this study can even
A show in which various topics are discussed informally be dated back to the origin of language itself. During the
and listeners, viewers or the studio audience are invited to Middle Ages, men were in charge of the standardization of
participate in the discussion (Merriam, 1965). In this study, grammar, vocabulary and structure. This caused the notion
classroom-based talk show has been chosen as an activity to and treatment that women’s use of English is unfitting in
gather data of what are the conversational styles based on creating language (Coates, 2004 as cited by Rathmayr,
gender. Additionally, talk show production refers to the 2014).
avenue where the participants can express their ideas when
given a specific topic. Genderlect is a term coined by Deborah Tannen
(1990), during the nineteen-seventies, to describe the
c) Genderlect variation in language used by genders (Hidalgo-Tenorio,
A controversial concept that finds its origins in the field of 2017). She also stated that there are other situations and
early sociolinguistics, after Weinrich’s (1953) claim that sex variables which may possibly influence the linguistic
can be a relevant variable in language contact situations, and performance of each gender, such as race, ethnicity, group,
that has repeatedly been argued to reinforce social age, job, social class, family income, as well as sociocultural
stereotyping (Motschenbacher, 2007). In this study,
The participants were the ones who answered the As the analyst, I was responsible for researching,
questions given by the moderator. Their answer was the analyzing, interpreting and presenting the data related to this
source of the collected data for this study. The groups were study which really helped me to further explain the results
separated by gender in order to materialize the purpose of of this study.
the study.
The moderators consisted of five (5) students who were Furthermore, since this study needed a video recording
given instructions to make sure that they were not biased to have a valid result, one of my roles was to be responsible
during the conversation. in recording the video during the classroom-based talk
show.
The moderators were responsible on making the
conversation going, giving questions and follow-up Moreover, being the researcher, it is also my
questions during the talk show production. responsibility to transcribe the conversations made by the
participants during the classroom-based talk show. Through
Lastly, the production team consists of twelve (12) the transcription, I and my debriefers were able to read the
female students. The production team were responsible conversations on verbatim that helped us make an easier
which made the flow of the classroom-based talk show in interpretation of the data. This also ensured that copies of
order. the documents can be distributed to further help in the
The data were purposively gathered through the classroom- analysis.
based Talk Show productions. Each conversation datum was
recorded from the productions and was transcribed and Lastly, as the researcher, it is also my responsibility to
analyzed. translate the transcribed data. I am responsible in
determining and understanding the meaning and context of
C. Role of the Researcher the material and I converted this into the second language
In qualitative studies, the role of the researcher is quite making sure on preserving the original meaning of the
different. The research is considered an instrument of data material.
collection (Denzin & Lincoln, 2003). This means that data
are mediated through the participants rather than through In order to guarantee the reliability and validity of the
inventories, questionnaires, or machines. According to analyzed conversational styles based on gender, the research
Greenbank (2003), as the qualitative researcher, I need to sought after two (2) Doctors in Applied Linguistics who also
describe relevant aspects of self, including any biases and became the reviewers of the analyzed data.
assumptions, any expectations, and experiences to qualify
my ability to conduct this research. In addition, it is useful D. Data Sources
for the qualitative researcher to keep a research journal Following the suggestive range of entries from Clark and
explicating personal reactions and reflections. Braun (2013) which is 10-100, this corpora-based study
used the recorded and transcribed conversation of male and
Simon (2011) stated that the qualitative researcher female participants in classroom-based Talk Show
should also explain if their role is emic – which is an insider, production. In this study, the researcher conducted a Talk
who is a full participant in activity, program, or Show with five (5) productions with different topics.
phenomenon, or the role is more etic – which comes from an
outside view, more of an objective viewer. There could be a Moreover, the video recorded and transcribed
great deal of variations in between – sometimes a researcher conversation classroom-based Talk Show production was
starts as an outsider and then becomes a member of the the primary source of data in this study. Through utilizing
group. Or the reverse occurs – the researcher starts as a different books, articles and videos that would relate to the
member of a group then becomes a more objective chosen topics, the gathered data were analyzed thoroughly.
observant. Then, the styles of the conversation were categorized and
interpreted.
Thus, being the researcher in this corpus-based
approach study, I considered myself as an etic which was an E. Data Collection Procedure
outsider view and was more of an objective viewer. The following procedures were undertaken in conducting
Furthermore, I transcribed the recorded conversation in this study as Creswell (2013) suggested:
verbatim. Transcribing is a difficult process, even for the First, the utmost way that I, the researcher, did was to
most experienced transcribers, but it must be done to secure an endorsement letter from the Dean of the Graduate
convert the spoken word to the written word to facilitate Education of St. Mary’s College of Tagum, Inc.
analysis. Second, was to ask for approval for the actual data
Significantly, being the researcher, my roles were as gathering; as the researcher, I asked permission to the
the analyst, recorder, transcriber, and translator. I was Schools Division Superintendent of Tagum and after which
responsible in reading, understanding and evaluating the I asked consent from the principal of the school where I
conducted the Classroom-Based Talk Show productions.
Then, I asked consent from the Master Teacher and Grade
The table above shows the conversational style and the a) Men Talk Faster than Women
comparative analysis of communicative behavior shown by Both female and male participants showed their
both men and women. The result has shown that women different conversational styles by manifesting their pacing in
used the highly involvement style and men the high speaking. As the data were analyzed and the number of
considerateness style, with following conversational styles seconds in giving their ideas and opinion, it was found out
mechanism such as speed, preference on topic/argument, that female participants showed a faster rate of speech
turn takings, directness, emotion/intimacy, and compared to men. The figure below illustrates the rate of
establishment of authority and strategy. speech of both male and female among the 5 different
productions.
Production 1 2 3 4 5
Number Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female
Total Number 917 2236 1347 2471 2476 3044 3676 2293 2174 3295
of Utterances words words words words words words words words words words
Total rate of 7.7 45.5 8.7 20 13.3 18.3 20.6 15.05 12.1 20.05
Speed min. min. min. min. min. min. min. min. min. min.
Table 2 : Percentage of Speech Rate per Production
It was shown in the result of study that upon pinakafirstna nag-love pudsaakoa, so saakoang
identifying the number of word utterances of male and mother, saakoang father silajudmakafeeljud ko na
female, at the same time its total rate of speed per love kanang love is sacrifice kay bisan pa mag,
production, it was found that men talked faster than women. bisan pa mag walaysud-an ing ana gud,
It was also observed that women tend to use fillers and made ihatagnalangnilasaimoing ana ba, kung
long pauses in connecting their thoughts and ideas. Likely, walasilaykwartaihatagnalangnilasaimo. So, para
women were indirect in their speeches. The following saakoa, love is like, love is sacrifice it’s because
excerpt below shows the comparison of statement from both kanang mas pilionnilana mas hatagan ka ug better
men and women. bisagwalanasila. (58 seconds) (PR2_2F)
Ahm, for me ahm if we talk ahm if we talk about (So, for me, love is creating emotion towards
abortion, it is a situation wherein ahm a mother others, but for me, love is a sacrifice which we
wants to ahm remove a fetus inside her womb. cannot always feel this way. For me, I felt this love
Ahm maybe, to ahm because of the fear of from my family since they are the ones who first
responsibility of being a mother or lack of loved me. A kind of love coming from my mother
resources ahm of ahm saving the child. (30 and father which even if they do not have viand or
secs.)(PR1_1F) money yet they always give you these because of
love. So, for me, love is a sacrifice because they
(For me, if we talk about abortion, it is a situation choose to give you a better life.) (58 seconds)
wherein the mother wants to remove a fetus inside (PR2_2F)
her womb. Maybe, because of the fear of
responsibility of being a mother, or maybe she During the second production which has a topic about
lacks the resources in saving the child.) love and relationship, men also gave their ideas about it.
The above statement is a response of the female So, for me, love is isa siyang… So, for me, love is
participant when she was asked about her idea pertaining isa siyangbugso ng damdaminngapanobayan,
abortion. It is noticeable that her answers have reached 30 nanapakahirapahmpigilan o kung sabisaya ang
seconds with 52 words. Also, for the same question, the men gugma isa siya ka
responded as: pagbatiganisakaugalingonnalisodkapugngan.
Once naa nay isa ka
So, for me is that abortion is ending the life of the taonamuabotsaimohaunyanahulog ka ana natao,
baby. Which is go with the flow nanajud. (30 seconds) (PR2_2M)
kananggipalaglagganinilaperowalanilagipadayun
ug panganak kay… (12 secs.) (PR1_2M) (So, for me, love is a feeling which is hard to
define and hard to control. Which is the same
(So, for me, abortion is ending the life of the baby. when we translate it into our mother-tongue. Once
This is aborting the child, since they do not want to there will be that one person who will come and
give birth to the child.) you will fell for that person, you will really pursue
it.) (30 seconds) (PR2_2M)
The male participants responded the same question
with 26 words in 12 seconds. The lesser the words uttered b) Preference on Topic/Argument
per minute, the higher the speech rate. Speakers have different conversational styles,
especially in delivering thoughts and ideas. The result
Also, in Production 2, when the students were asked revealed that both men and women have different
about their views about love and having relationship, both of preferences expressing their ideas in presenting
them gave their ideas about the given task. topics/arguments. It was shown that when women were
asked about a certain topic, they manifested that they
So, for me, ahm so love is like. So, for me, love is preferred to present their ideas by means of relating it to
ahm create emotion towards other but ahm for me their personal life, in fact, they preferred topics including
jud, love is sacrifice dli lang man affective talk. Among the five productions; abortion, views
satananpanahonmaka-feel tag love towards other about love and having relationship, depression, social
sadilinimokadugo. So akoamafeelnako ang love media etiquettes, and SOGIE Bill, only in the topic of
towards my family kay sila man jud ang social media where women gave lesser inputs and ideas.
39%
61%
Female Male
Figure 1 shows that female speakers used 61% of questions give the speaker the power to elicit a response from
compared to 39% of the occurrences in the male speakers’ listeners. There were 98 WH-questions found in the corpora
speech. Questions are powerful linguistic forms as they and 61% of it comes from women, and 39 % from men.
Fig. 2. Male Antconc Concordance display for the word Unsa (what)
Using the Antconc software application, it was found (For me, it is a difficult decision. Then, there you can apply
that male participants used unsa in questioning with 26 hits your critical thinking skills that I have learned from our
or appearance in the corpora. The word unsaoriginated lesson. So, what should I be thinking? If I would abort the
fromthe participants’ mother tongue which means what. It child, or I would let the baby live. So, for me, I would take
was usually used in asking question such as giunsa (how) care of the baby, since it comes from me.) (PR1_1M)
asa (where), kanus-a (when) kinsa (who) as it was indicated
in the following sentences below. The sample statement from the corpora above was the
response of the male participant when he was asked about
…….ahmkuan sad kanang mu-post ko kung the issue of abortion.
kanangnaayimportante ug mga occasions ra pud, mga
family reunion ingon ana siyakanangmga occasions ……Ang time, pagmawala ang time walana kay bonding
pudnanahitabosaakoang life ug sa family, sa friends, so pagmuabotsa point namuingon ang
unsaakongginaapilankaron, kana ra pudakongginakuan, parents naunsamanang social media, kung madaot ug
ginapostdidto and nothing else. (PR4_4M) mawalanasiya, kinsa man ka? Asa man ka padulong?
(PR1_4M)
(…I will only post when there are events and occasion, like
family reunions, and occasions about what happened in my (Time would just pass without spending it with the family
life, and what have I attended, only those things, and and friends, so it would come to a point where my parents
nothing else.) would say “what is in social media, if it will be gone, where
will it lead you?) (PR1_4M)
Ahm, para saakoakuansiyakanangkuansiyana decision
kananglisodpero then ddtoananimo ma-apply ang imohang The highlighted words are the WH-questions used as a
thinking ang imong critical thinking based on our lesson on linguistic feature in conversation which was used as a style
reading and writing. So, unsa man ang in delivering thoughts. One of the goals in studying gender
akoanghunahunaon? Kung akoa bang ipalaglag or speech-style is to examine whether question asking is, as
akoangbuhionnalang so for me, buhionnako kay previously claimed, predominantly a characteristic of
akoagudna, gikannasakoangmgakamot. (PR1_1M) women’s style. It is therefore worth noting the frequency
of occurrence of questions individually and by gender.
Fig. 3. Female Antconc Concordance Display for the Word Unsa (what)
The result of the study revealed the total statement presenters used more fillers than female presenters. This
utilized fillers of both female and male is 116 in all of these indicates that the fillers are often used while the male
were composed from the 5 productions. Female participants speaker was groping for words and this affected his fluency
obtained 50 occurrence of filler ahm(uhm), while male and confidence in his conversation.
participants used the filler ahm66 times. It shows that male
The sample statement above is the answer given (For me, we need the social etiquettes because we
by a female participant …(PR4_2F), when she was should be careful in sharing, for we don’t know its
asked about cyber bullying in social media. The use of effect to others, for we have different thoughts. Others
filler was manifested when she was thinking of the may understand wrongly, it may be a joke for others but
right word to be used. Also, same with the male not to others.)
participant as he was asked the same topic about the
use of social media. The filler uhm was mentioned twice in a statement.
Also, it was used as the first word in the statement. This
So, teenagers. So, you are referring saatoa? So ang finding indicates that the male presenters used fillers at a
uhm ang main reason gyudnganongahm, para saakoa much higher frequency than the female presenters.
ha kanangnagagamitgudkuanmga social media
kanang. Ang social media man gud kay kanangnaga- Aside from ahm, kanang, kuan, and like was also
entertain siyabakanangahm, hmm. Dili lang man used by both female and male participants in the corpora.
gudsiya isa lang, dili lang siya for entertainment, They are Cebuano dialect which likely means as uhm from
makakuha man pud ka dira ug information then ahm, the sentence with no change in content
isa pudkanang, ahm para saakoakanang,
maonaakongginapagawsansakongmgagibati. Mao i) Hedges
nasiya. (PR4_2M) Women’s speech is often described as ‘tentative’,
and this assertion is linked to the claim that women use
(So, teenagers. Are referring to us? So, the main more hedges. Hedges are linguistic forms which express
reason for me, those who used social media it is for the speaker’s certainty or uncertainty about the topic under
entertainment. It is not just one, it is not just for discussion
entertainment but also, we can get information and
that’s my outlet of my feelings.)
HEDGES
35%
65%
Male Female
The result shows that female participants used more hedges female participants. Figure 5 provides evidence that female
than male participants. Out from 345 hedges occurred like speakers used more hedges (65%) compared to male
for me, maybe, not necessarily, mostly, and as general, 120 speakers (35%) and this finding supports Lakoff’s claim that
of it were found among male participants and 225 among women tend to use more ‘hedges compared to men.
Intensifiers
43%
57%
Male Female
Figure 6 revealed that among 149 intensifiers used such as (So, let us differentiate sadness and depression. So for
very, so much, and much, 85 of it was from the female me, the difference between the two is that everyone of
participants which comprised of 57% while the male us may experience sadness, because even simple
participants have 64 intensifiers used which comprised of 43 things can make us sad, like when we could not get
%. Female participants used intensifiers more than the male attention from friends and no replies from crush, it can
participants. However, the results are not consistent because only be felt in a very short time, unlike depression,
not all female participants as to male participants used we can look for some ways to overcome sadness.)
intensifier at all in his speech. Thus, the assumption cannot (PR3_1F)
be made that male speakers used intensifiers at a higher rate.
On the other hand, the third male participant
The sentences below are example of the statements also gave his idea about depression.
from female and male participants using the following
intensifiers when they were both asked by the moderator So, if the environment is very positive, kana pudna ang
about their ideas about depression. imohapungsilingan, ang imohang friends and
imohang family, magkuanpudmagiging happy pud.
So let us differentiate sadness and depression. So for Magiging positive pud. Pero pa gang family sige rag
me, ang difference between the two is that ang sadness sad, sige lang ug ano, lahipud ang judgment ang
daghan ta makafeel ana tanan because sa simple ilahangginabuhat, muanhisilasa school mas very
nabutangmapahimo tag sad, happy silaunyapaguli sad napudsila. (PR3_3M)
bisagkanangdilipagtagadsaimong friends ug sadilipag
reply saimong crush so makafeelkag sadness ana (So, if the environment is very positive, like your
kaysasa depression ang kana man gung sadness is friends, neighbors and relatives are happy, you will
kuannasiyakanang it can be felt for a very short time, also be happy. You will become positive as well. But
short period of time lang nasiya kay ma overcome if the family is sad, they will be very happy in coming
natonasiyapinaagisapagpangitag ways para to school and sad upon coming home.) (PR3_3M)
mapalipay ka and dali ra kaayonasiya ma overcome.
(PR3_1F)
AFFIRMATIVES
Male Female
21%
79%
l) Adjective Types
Adjectives are used to give compliments in conversations. As the corpora were analyzed, these major adjectives were used in
the corpora.
Adjectives Frequency Sample Sentence
Different 28 So, we have different perception of what is life…(PR3_3M)
Mali (bad or wrong) 23 …when you know that they have bad comments for you…(PR5_4F)
short 20 …because our life is very short... (PR3_1F)
depressed 16 …why we are depressed because we need attention. (PR3_3M)
easy 16 …easy to know and it is easy to understand…(PR4_4M)
Adjectives
Figure 8 shows the percentage of the use of adjectives as linguistic conversational style. The result has shown that among
367 with 56% adjectives occurred, 161 or 44% of it was from male participant of the talk-show, and 206 of it was from female
participants. It clearly shows that female speakers used significantly more adjectives than males. The following sentences below
are examples of responses of both male and female participants.
The word different as adjective was the most by Tannen (1990) will be analyzed as to how it affects the
frequently used adjective in the corpora of school-based speech styles of both men and women.
Talk Show, however, the result has shown that it was mostly
derived from one participant (PR3). D. Conversational Style Linguistic Feature: Questions
a) Women Ask More Questions than Men
C. How Gender Affects the Conversational Styles in Different studies have shown different results as to
Classroom-Based Talk Show Production the ways how male and female ask questions during a
From the first question of the study, it identifies what are discourse or in the discourse community. Studies concluded
the conversational styles of male and female present in their as well that tag questions unintentionally turn into a
classroom-based talk show production of which these declarative statement which shows that speakers are
productions include questions, fillers, intensifiers, uncertain and assertive. Further, studies indicated as well
affirmatives and adjective types. It is now in this research that women use more tag questions than men.
question that those identified conversational styles presented
Ah, according to the study, abortion is a process Consequently, if we are going to analyze the influence
or the removal of an embryo or fetus inside the of gender in the fillers as conversational style, it can be
mother’s womb. Ahm it is to remove ahm an significantly noted that male speakers are the ones who are
embryo or a fetus in a 5 to 7 months maybe hiding composed upon giving their answers before speaking which
then ahm that process is unnecessary means that they are composing first their answers before
nasiyasaatoang society or even speaking. Moreover, female speakers are the ones who were
saatoangkuansaatoasainyohasababae. Then for eager and fervent in answering questions which resulted that
me, kanangkasagaranpudsamgani-engaged they are already using fillers or even started answering with
anangmgakuanmga practices kanangmga the use of fillers.
situations kay ang mga teenagers
kanangmgababae because Thus, with the use of AntConc, it came out that female
ahmilahangkuannagkamalisilag way, speakers used more fillers compared to male speakers. From
kuanilangpagka-romantic sa isa ka lalake. Ni- the five classroom-based talk show productions, female
engage sila ana speakers used a total of four hundred five (405) fillers while
namgabutangtungodsawalasilakabalosailahanggb male speakers used only a total of three hundred eighty-two
uhattungodsapagkalamisakuansaatoangkinabuhi. (382) fillers. Though, both genders used fillers in the whole
speech production process, but it is significantly noted that a
(Ah, according to the study, abortion is a process difference of twenty-nine (29) fillers from both genders
or the removal of an embryo or fetus inside the indicated that female speakers tend to be more eager and
mother’s womb. Ahm it is to remove ahm an impatient to answer questions and can be classified to be
embryo or a fetus in 5 to 7 months maybe because more hesitant upon delivering answers or speeches.
they are hiding it, which is an unnecessary process
for our society, for us or even for the girls. For me, F. Conversational Style Linguistic Feature: Intensifiers
the one who engaged to that practice or situation is a) Both Men and Women Use Intensifiers for Emphasis
kanangteenagers, especially the girls because ahm Intensifiers can be expressed to be both referential
they take the wrong way on being so romantic with meaning (degrees of certainty) and affective meaning
boys. They engaged with things of which they are (politeness). With the previous researches conducted,
oblivious of what they are doing because life intensifiers have also been called as boosters, strengtheners,
seems so wonderful.) (PR1_1M) and also up-graders. In English grammar, it is the adverbs or
adverbial phrase that strengthens the meaning of other
Para saakoakanangkuan depression kay ma expressions and show emphasis (Fuchs, 2017).
feelsnimokanangsagolsagolnaganiparehasanang
problems sa financial kana judtapos ang kuansa However, during the conduct of the classroom-based
depression parehassaiyanggiingon (refers to P3B) talk show production of my participants which are the
long period of time kanangsa sadness ma students, most common words that they are using that show
feelgihaponnimoperokanangmapaaginimosamasol emphasis or extreme meaning with the other word or group
venimosadali ra nabutang. of words are the Cebuano term, kaayo then the adverb very
and a little of the Cebuano term sobra. Again, the
(For me, kanangkuan depression is that you can appearance of the Cebuano terms is highly observable
already feel mix emotions just like financial because the medium of speaking in the conduct of the
problems. Then, kuan in depression, just like what speech production is both English and the mother-tongue of
he said (Refer to P3B), it’s a long period of time the participants.
kanangthe sadness, you can still feel it but you can
resolve it to the easiest way that you know.) To show emphasis with the appearance and occurrence
P3_P2B of the intensifiers as used by the participants, samples are
illustrated below.
c) Less Fillers for Men Proved That They Are Confident Actually,dili mana siyadapati-implement kay mas
Than Women mugaraba ang term, kay
From the perspectives of the male speakers, it is daghankaayogmahitabokunwari kana
noticeable from the first sample above that male speaker are maimplementnasiya, kunwari ang bata,
the ones who spoke directly or answered directly the dilisasiyahatagan ug gender pagkaanakniya kay
question if they do have an answer on their mind. They do dapatsiya ang mamilisaiyang gusto na gender
not have fillers early in their speech production; thus, it can pagdakoniya so saiyang birth certificate so ang
be gleaned that they are confident of their answers. ibutangsasa gender niya kay “XX” or hashtag
However, just like female speakers, male speakers opted to hashtag kay dilipaman sure siyasaiyang gender.
use fillers in the middle of their speech delivery. By this, it
can be concluded that even male speakers as well are (Actually, it shouldn’t be implemented because
hesitant of their answers at some point of time during their there will be a lot of things that might happen if it
(So, depression versus sadness. Sadness, it is a This chapter contains the different conversational
reaction of a specific situation while depression for styles of both men and women found in the classroom-based
me, is an illness that could possibly kill a person. talk show production with significant discussions which
You can do things that could cause you death, you explain its importance in context of speaking with due
will commit a suicide. Sadness is like a reaction in consideration of the gender of the speaker. Further, the
a specific situation, you are sad because you are different gathered data which are the five productions of talk
hungry. That is in a short period of time, right? Are show discussing different topics became the basis of the
you sad if you don’t have something to eat? discussion and summative deliberations that would form the
Sometimes if you don’t have money, you will be conclusions of this research.
sad. So, depression is for longer period of time.
You are depressed not only mentally and A. Conversational Styles of Men and Women Comes From
emotionally or those factors, and that might affect the Classroom-based Talk Show Production
yourself. For example, with your social being, you Speaking seems to be an essential skill in English since it
lack socialization. You can say that you are not is the way that allows people to communicate with another,
fond of socializing with others because you are not to socialize with different people and a way that allows
accepted by the society and you do not have also people to be united and understood. However, one factor
money, right? Then, that is another financial issue. that greatly influence the speaking skills and communication
Next is with your spiritual being, you lack advices of a person is the gender. Thus, it is now in context of the
from your parents and then your mental state of current research to study the conversational styles of men
being has been affected. Sometimes you do not and women and how it affects its communication process.
know anymore how to weigh what is good and
what is bad and then if all of those four factors a) Speed
combined, it will cause depression while sadness is In speaking, proper pauses and juncture is very much
like if we are to going to label it, sadness is 1 out important in order to assure the fluency of the whole speech.
of 10 while depression is 10 over 10.) Further, this certain feature in speech communication affects
the delivery of the speaker upon dealing in the discourse
b) Men Can Be More Verbose Than Women Depending community. In context of the current study, it was noticeable
on the Topic that women showed longer speeches within a minute
From the given samples above, it is a sample compared to men who has a lesser rate of speech.
situation from the third production of the classroom-based
talk show task of which the moderator of the talk show Additionally, it was found out that male and female
asked about the insights and opinions of both speakers as to speakers were not significantly different with regard to their
what is depression for them. Both have shared answers and quality of simultaneous interpretation and communication.
opinions as to what is depression of which it can be However, the findings showed that both genders did not
significantly noted that the male speaker is more verbose in hold the same with regard to their speed of speaking in their
explaining the topic by giving different situations and native language and it was shown that females produced
scenarios. Also, another indication that male speaker is faster oral production in comparison to the male interpreters.
verbose is the time allotment of which the male speaker Therefore, it seems quite logical not to generalize the
obtained a total of 2 minutes and 19 seconds. existence of gender-related differences in translation studies
on all issues of translation and interpreting. As the results of
On the other hand, the female speaker can be classified the current study, it indicated that gender-related differences
as a direct speaker upon giving explanations for the reason are not observed in all issues related to translation and
of, in answering the same question, female speaker interpreting.
answered the question within 58 seconds only which means Further, it is added that on the average, while both men and
that the female defines directly the difference between women exhibited the main trend, men conveyed more
sadness and depression by giving its definition and at least information than women at the same speech rate (Priva,
one example. 2017). However, it is added that women may tend to be
more concerned with making sure their listeners understand
Thus, after analyzing adjectives as a conversational
what they are saying. For example, in conversation, women
style as to how gender affects it, there is a salient result
are more likely than men to "backchannel," or provide
observed. It is now the male speakers who are more verbose
verbal cues like "uh, huh" to confirm understanding as the
compared to women upon answering question and it is now
dialogue proceeds.
women who are direct. Further, we will not limit this
observation to all of the five productions because it should b) Preference on Topic or Argument
be noted as well that every production discusses different Different speakers also varied differently with their
topic. One of the reasons could be that, with depression topic preference. They do have corresponding topics in mind