Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Abstract:- It is a useful exercise in this thematic issue to At the beginning of a new human life stands the
study the African view of marriage and family life, the affection and utter love of two people, father and
Catholic position on marriage and family life, the mother. This love and its fruitfulness is based on
Church’s early doctrine on marriage and family life, differences of sexes. The differences of sexes,
Vatican II, Post-Vatican II and current considerations, however, are not only of significance in the
more Post-Conciliar teaching. In this article the author creation of new life. (Wo)Man’s sexual
intends to study the evaluation in treating about the differentiation permeates his/her whole person
Latin Catholic Church’s view of marriage and family in always and forever; it stamps all [of a person’s] …
relation to African culture. The article will pay attention actions and is creative also under aspects other than
to the way marriage and family in relation to African procreation.5
culture has been described in the texts by the Catholic
magisteium. Consequently, the evaluation and pastoral Today, marriage and family are facing many
recommendations are suggested. challenges that call for great attention. In Familiaris
Consortio, Pope John Paul II writes that “as much as and
Keywords:- The Latin Catholic Church; Scripture, Marriage perhaps more than any other institution (marriage) has been
and Family, African Culture, Doctrine; Vatican II; Laity, beset by the many profound and rapid changes that have
Evaluation and Pastoral Recommendations. affected society and culture”6 The goal of this paper, then, is
to look at Christian marriage and family in the modern
I. INTRODUCTION world and in the context of African culture, Some realities
that affect Christian marriage and family are of critical
In the introductory part of this article, it is noted from concern. According to St. Augustine, as quoted by Pope
the well-known author Karl H. Peschke that to be human is John Paul II, “history is not simply a fixed progression
to be born of a man and a woman.1 There is need for a man towards what is better, but rather an event of freedom, and
and a woman for a family to be created. The beginning of a even a struggle between freedoms that are in mutual
new human life is a sacred moment of God’s wisdom and conflict. It is, according to the well-known expression of St.
powerful work in humanity. God’s continuing creative Augustine, ‘a conflict between two loves: the love of God to
power is especially evident in marriage and family (Gen 2: the point of disregarding self, and the love of self to the
24; Mt19: 6).2 A child is born in cooperation between point of disregarding God.”7 The Pope asserts that “only an
human beings and God, whereby humans remain the co- education for love rooted in faith can lead to the capacity of
creator, not the author of life. Any marriage between interpreting ‘the signs of the times,’ which are the historical
husband and wife is instituted by God, who is forever the expression of this twofold love.”8 In the same way, Pope
author of life.3 The power to cooperate with God is Benedict XVI also says that “humanity today is
bestowed on parents as they give new life to a child. This unfortunately experiencing great division and sharp conflicts
cooperation begins with conception and birth and is which cast dark shadows on its future.”9 All of this is a call
completed in the education of the child. God nourishes, to pastors and people of good will to pay attention to the
loves and guides the new human life through its parents who reality of the human family.
have a serious and joyful responsibility as a consequence.4
According to Karl H. Peschke, It is the Church’s responsibility to look at this situation
in a critical manner. The concern should be to maintain
those values that constitute the foundation of the institution
of Christian marriage and family. It is important to help
Christians and others to become aware of the ultimate
1
Cf. K. H. Peschke, Christian Ethics: Moral Theology in meaning and truth of marriage and family life. As the
the Light of Vatican, Vol. II (Bangalore Theological Second Vatican Council asserts, “the Church offers her
Publication in India, 1987), 372. Peschke (SVD) was born
on the 12th August 1932 in Breslau, Schlesien. He is the
Professor of Moral theology, who has written many works
5
on theological and moral teachings K. H. Peschke, Christian Ethics: Moral Theology in the
2
Cf. Pope John Paul II, Familiaris Consortio, no 19 Light of Vatican, Vol. II, 373.
3 6
Ibid John Paul II, Familiaris Consortio, 1981, no. 1
4 7
Cf. K. H. Peschke, Christian Ethics: Moral Theology in John Paul II, Familiaris Consortio, no. 5; Cf. also St.
the Light of Vatican, Vol. II, 373. See also, The “Dutch Augustine, De Civitate Dei, XIV, 28; CSEL 40, II, 56-57
Catechism” for Adults: A new Catechism. Catholic Faith for 8
Ibid
9
Adults (London: Burns and Oates, 1967), 381ff., quoted in Message of His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI for the
Peschke’s works in the same text of Christian Ethics Celebration of the World Day of Peace (2008), no. 14
10
Gaudium et Spes, no. 52. In Austin Flannery. Ed. Vatican
Council II: The Conciliar and Post Conciliar Documents
New Revised Edition (Pasay City: Paulines, 2006), no. 52
11 17
Laurent Magesa, African Religion: The Moral Traditions William G. Blum, Forms of Marriage: Monogamy
of Abundant Life (New York: Orbis Books 1997), 115 Reconsidered (Nairobi: AMECEA Gaba Publications,
12
Ibid, 125 1989), 112
13 18
Magesa, African Religion, 115. Ibid; see also Aylward Shorter, African Culture, An
14
William A. Haviland, Anthropology (10th ed.) (Belmont, Overview: Socio-Cultural Anthropology (Kenya, Nairobi:
CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, 2003); Paulines Publications Africa, 1998), 91
19
cf., https://www.purplemotes.net/2014/08/24/virilocality- In Farley, 87
20
polygyny-evolution-communication/ (accessed on In Farley, 87
20/12/2016) 21
J. Simister, “Domestic violence and female genital
15
Margaret A Farley, Just Love: A Framework for Christian mutilation in Kenya: effects of ethnicity and education.”
Sexual Ethics (New York and London: Continuum, 2006), Journal of Family Violence (2010), 25(3):247–57.
22
83 Catholic News Service (September 23, 2014); see also,
16
Eugene Hillmann, Polygamy Reconsidered: African https://www.americamagazine.org/issue/pope-names-five-
Plural Marriage and the Christian Churches (New York: women-international-theological-commission (accessed,
Orbis Books, 1975), 88 09/09/2021)
In the Old Testament, the sacredness of marriage is An example is St. Augustine of Hippo (354-430 AD).
rooted in the creation narrative (Gen 2:18-24; 1:28; 24:60; He lived in the declining years of the Roman Empire.
Ps 127:3). Polygamy and monogamy as forms of marriage According to him, marriage is characterized by tria bona (or
are also evident there (Gen 4:19; 1Sam 1:15; 1Kgs 11:13). three goods), 30 namely, first, there is the bonum prolis, (the
Childlessness is seen as a misfortune (Lev 20:20; Is 47:9). good of offspring). In the natural order, this good serves the
Adultery is forbidden (Ez 16:53-63; Ex 20:14). From the human race and its survival. The direct result of marital
beginning, in Genesis, marriage is identified as a union of intercourse is the procreation of offspring. The one, sole
one man and one woman becoming one flesh (cf. Gen 1:28; justification for engaging in intercourse in marriage is to
9:7; 17:2-5, 16; 28:3; 35:11; 48:3-4).23 In the New achieve this goal, the good of procreation. Second, there is
Testament, marriage is a state created by God (Mt 19: 1-12; the bonum fidei (the good of fidelity that excludes adultery).
Mk.10:6-8).24 Monogamy is the only form that God willed It is primarily the human experience of friendship and the
as is explicitly demonstrated by Jesus and St. Paul (Mt formation of a community as a direct result of human social
19:1ff; 2:27-32; Mk10:2-12; Rom 7:2-3; Eph 5:22-23; Rom nature. It is a remedy to all sorts of sexual tendencies and
1:24-27; 1Cor 7:2-16; 6:9; 6:12-18; Eph 4:19).25 Other feelings. Third, there is the bonum sacramenti, (the good of
forms of marriage are repudiated. Marriage places sexuality durability or the indissolubility of the marital bond that
under the firm basis of love (1Cor.7)26 and is portrayed as a forbids divorce). Christian marriage is a sign, a holy symbol
symbol of Christ’s union with His Church (Eph 5:21-33, of the relationship between Christ and the church. For this it
1Tim 3:3-5). cannot be dissolved. 31 Augustine believed in the good of
marriage and openly praised it, just as Paul did when he
However, one should take care to avoid wrote: “Let marriage be honorable among all.” Augustine
fundamentalism and oversimplification of the biblical assumes the teachings of Paul further by defending marriage
passages. A balanced and critical approach is needed in the and the positive aspects of it, and in trying to restore its
use of scripture to tackle moral issues regarding ethical honor. “Marriage, I say, is good, and can be defended by
situations.27 The language of scripture demands right reason against all charges.”32
hermeneutics in order to apply scriptural texts to issues of
sexuality and marriage, for example. Thomas Aquinas (1225–74 AD) focused on three
characteristics of marriage, known as three officium.33 The
IV. THE CHURCH’S EARLY DOCTRINE ON
MARRIAGE AND FAMILY LIFE
manuscripts containing works of Augustine or ascribed to
In the first centuries, Christians were busy defending him in order to make time-consuming research in this field
the goodness of marriage against various claims of easier.
29
Gnosticism, namely, the Gnostics, Ascetics and Encratites. For instance, St. Justin the Martyr, Athenagoras, Marcus
For that purpose they referred to several scriptural texts Minucius Felix, Clement of Alexandria, Origen, St. Jerome,
(Gen 1: 2), where the bond of husband and wife is St. Ambrose, St. John Chrysostom, St. Augustine of Hippo,
confirmed by the Creator. This can also be seen in Mt 19:1- and St. Thomas Aquinas.
12 and Mk 10:1-12 where Jesus speaks of marriage
30
Cf., Roy J. Deferrari, “Introduction”. In The Fathers of
according to the original intention of the Creator. However, the Church, Volume 27: Treatises on Marriage and Other
some Christians interpreted the scriptural data according to Subjects (America: The Catholic University of America
the rigid conception of the stoics, permitting marriage only Press, 1955), 4; cf., Russell Shaw, ed., “The Goods of
for the sake of procreation and not for pleasure.28 They were marriage”. In Encyclopedia of Catholic Doctrine, Our
Sunday Visitor, 1997.
31
Cf., Roy J. Deferrari, The Fathers of the Church, Volume
23
The Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition, 27: Treatises on Marriage and Other
(Nairobi: Paulines Publishers, 1994), no. 1602; see also, Subjects. “Introduction,” (The Catholic University of
Gen 1:26-27; Rev 19:7-9 America Press, 1955), 4;
24
Cf., Darton, ed., The New Jerusalem Bible (Study Edition) see also, http://www.cormacburke.or.ke/node/339; see also,
(London: Longman and Todd Ltd, 1994), which explains accessed, 30/02/2017
Jesus’ teaching when he was challenged by the Pharisees 32
St. Augustine, “De bono coniugali”. The Fathers of the
and the Scribes on the issue of marriage (see, Mathew 19: Church, Volume 27: Treatises on Marriage and Other
1-12; Mk.10:6-8) Subjects (America: The Catholic University of America
25
Ibid Press, 1955), 39
26 33
Karl H. Peschke, Christian Ethics: Moral Theology in the Cf. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa theologiae I-II, q. 91, a.
Light of Vatican II (Birmingham: Wipf and Stock 2; see also, Catechism of the Catholic Church on “The
Publishers, 1997), 395 Effects Of The Sacrament Of Matrimony” (nos. 1638-1642),
27
Stephen E. Fowl and Jones L. Gregory, Reading in and “The Goods And Requirements of Conjugal Love” (nos.
Communion: Scripture and Ethics in Christian Life (Grand 1643-1654). Augustine’s most extensive writing on
Rapids: William B. Eerdmans, 1991), 45 marriage, at 30 years of age, is found in his Scriptum,
28
These writings are found in CSEL The CSEL publishes or Commentary on the Sentences of Peter Lombard, much of
special catalogues for the large extant corpus of medieval which was later edited and published after his death as
The document of Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia, is of The issue of divorce and remarriage is a complex
great importance on the issue of marriage and family. In reality where the unitive and indissoluble dimensions of
this document, the Pope discusses the family as well as marriage are concerned. However, Julie Clague says that:
many other moral-pastoral challenges facing marriage and
family today.51 Pope Francis dwells on conjugal love as These issues should be discussed soberly in order
related to procreation and education of children, who are the to remove any ambiguity. Although these ethical
ultimate crown of this love. Children, who are the supreme challenges threaten marriage and its meaning and
gift of marriage, contribute very substantially to the welfare nature, the Church and other stakeholders of the
of their parents. Pope Francis affirms this when he says that: human family must be ready to protect God’s plan
of marriage and family against anything that
Love is made fruitful, for children are a gift. Each devalues and dehumanizes in the context of
one is unique and irreplaceable … We love our marriage and family. 56
children because they are children, not because
they are beautiful, or look or think as we do, or Evangelizing and educating children, especially
embody our dreams. We love them because they teenagers, is necessary. Pope Francis points out that since
“adolescents usually have issues with authority and rules, it
is best to encourage their own experience of faith and to
45
Ibid provide them with attractive testimonies that win them over
46
Collins, The Code of Canon Law (in English translation) by their sheer beauty”57 The Pope continues to say that
(Landon: Collins Liturgical Publications, 1983), Canons, “Parents need to consider what they want their children to
1141, 1151-1151; cf., The Catechism of the Catholic be exposed to, and this necessarily means being concerned
Church, nos. 2382-2391
47
The Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition,
52
nos. 1601-1602 Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia, no. 170
48 53
John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Centesimus Annus, Ibid, 174
54
39: AAS 83 (1991), 841; cf., no. 212 The Catechism of the Catholic Church, nos. 1644-1645;
49
Familiaris Consortio, no. 20 see also, in Amoris laetitia (The Joy of Love) Pope Francis
50
Ibid., no. 14 quotes Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Theologiae I–II, q. 27, a. 1
51
Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia, Chapter One explains the “on marriage and love”
55
definition of the family in the light of the Word and Chapter Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia, no. 232
Two discusses the experiences and challenges of families. 56
Julie Clague, “Catholics, Families and the Synod of
Other Chapters give us the way forward. See also, Raymond Bishops: View from the Pews” Heythrop Journal LV
J De Souza, "Reading the fine print in Amoris (2014), 985-1008
57
Laetitia". Catholic Herald (Catholic Herald Limited, 2016) See Ibid, 288 and 60.