Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Abstract:- Sweet potatoes are a highly nutritious food produce favorable samples for all treatments. Sensory
group, they continue to gain interest on account of the evaluation established that fermentation was a favored
diversity of the tuber and the number of products that pretreatment option whilst Victoria, Tsumaya and
can be developed from the tuber itself. This is true on the Chingovha were amongst the popular varieties and as
global scale, however; locally the amount of such such should be formulated into sweet potato based
products on market is minimal. Such should be available instant porridge.
to cater to gluten intolerant and celiac disease niches and
also exhaust the favorable SP production cycle. The Keywords:- Water and Oil Holding Capacity, Emulsification
overall purpose of this study is to determine the best Stability, Acceptability.
variety and treatment for flour production, for use in the
formulation of a sweet potato based instant porridge. I. INTRODUCTION
Seven varieties of sweet potato tubers: Chingovha (white
flesh), Delvia (orange flesh), Irene (yellow flesh), Victoria Background to Study
(orange flesh), Namanga (orange flesh), Alicia (yellow The Great Famine of Ireland of 1845 to 1849 (Kianely,
flesh) and Tsumaya (pale yellow flesh) were harvested at 1997); the drastic and tumultuous crumbling of the Irish
physiological maturity and processed to flour on a lab- economy and government is termed throughout history as a
based pilot via thermal processing. The fresh tubers result of natural events. Potato blight infected all potato
were washed, sliced and treated with Ascorbic acid to crops to the point of significantly slashing the nation’s
prevent browning. Following ascorbic acid population, stirring uprisings and causing widespread unrest
pretreatment; for treatment 1 fresh tubers were dried throughout Europe (Kelly & Fotheringham, 2011). Although
immediately, slices for treatment 2 were parboiled for 10 drastic; the ‘Hard Times’ emphasized the significance of
minutes before drying whilst slices for treatment 3 were tubers and even related them to the well-standing of the
fermented prior to drying for 1-3 days in 5% brine and European economies. As the time lapsed with growing
1% sucrose solution. Post-drying: the slices were ground populations and increased food demand, this prompted
to fine powder and the flour product assessed on both further classification of crops and their relevance. A study
functional and physiochemical properties with particular was carried out (Bhattachary, 2011) in which sweet potato
emphasis for use in instant porridge formulation. A was ranked position 5 for crops that feed the world. The
Randomized Block Design was used for the experiment study concludes that Ipomoea batatas although highly under-
while sensory evaluation wase used to determine product utilized had vast potential in that it maintained agricultural
acceptability. The product was assessed according to relevance in withstanding adverse abiotic and biotic stresses,
flour quality (color, emulsification stability, oil and nutritional composition, ease of propagation, source of
water holding capacity, foreign matter and moisture subsistence, ‘famine relief’ and immense industrial value
content), treatment effect (before and after processing such as in the extraction of starch for the production of
based on protein content, starch content, phenolic animal feed. The study further emphasized the significance
content, gluten content, Beta carotene content). Together of the tuber especially relative to the nutritional composition
these parameters determined that the ideal mode of with respect to derivatives that could be attained from the
treatment for flour production was fermentation in that tuber and an outline of the ease of processing.
it exhibited the least nutritive reductive effect across all
varieties. There were significant differences (p-value) With that in mind; it is unfortunate that the vast of
between varieties with respect to flour quality amongst Africa, which contains the most developing countries
oil and water holding capacities, moisture content but (Rampa. F., 2011) , regard the crop as ‘poor person’ food,
not for emulsification stability. The most ideal treatment which as a result has caused the lag in exhausting tuber
was fermentation in that amongst the analyzed properties by means of sweet potato processing. In fact, in
parameters; the greatest nutrient retention was observed Africa from the period before 2010 the crop was mostly
for fermented samples. Tsumaya was observed to grown for subsistence through backyard farming.
Fig 1 Sweet potato production quantity curve in Zimbabwe for the period 1998 to 2019
(Zimbabwe: Sweet potatoes production quantity (tons), 2020)
To support this, it was highlighted that during the least gelation concentration, gelatinization temperature and
period between 2005-2011 Zimbabwe’s sweet potato bulk density and moisture content. The study highlighted
production was an estimated 2% whilst China was well that some functional properties such as those that can be
above 75% (Stathers, 2018). The great gap in production found in potato and green gram flour can enhance the
yield could be attributed to the public perception of the bulk nutritional quality of value-added products, such as fat,
tuber in Africa and the large scope availability of post- vitamins and minerals. Functional characteristics are
harvest technologies in China. China attributes its large fundamental physicochemical properties which in turn
sweet potato production to the presence and means for post- provide an indication of purpose. Such include foreign
harvest processing technologies. The development of such matter, nutritional value, quality and product acceptability.
technologies has led to various processing products in
China, for example, sweet potato noodles, vermicelli and Foreign matter is used as a highlight of product purity
sheet jelly, wedges, chips, starch, flour and organic products and assessor of effect of processing. It is often identified as
including ethanol (Zhang, 2009). Contrarily the local any kind of outside contaminant introduced to a food
perception is centered largely on the bulk alone; the tuber is product at any point in its production or distribution.
mostly harvested, transacted and consumed as is and no (Dogan. H., 2010). As such foreign matter provides an
processing technologies have been publicized to date. indication of how safe the food may be for consumption by
identifying the consequence of processing. In processing
Flour is one of the products that can be harnessed from glass is common under foreign matter. For example; under
the tubers processed via thermal processing. The qualities cereal processing, foreign matter is accounted for under
that make up ‘good’ or ‘acceptable’ flour vary immensely. It refractions, of which these are to include filth and any
has been alluded that certain characteristic may be used as particles separated from product during processing: sieved
quality indicators. (Zhygunov. D., 2019) sums up and filth- particles of specific size ranges separated
estimates the quality indicators as follows: whiteness 1-71 quantitatively from product by use of sieves. (FSSAI.,
units, gluten deformation index 40-100 units, gluten content 2016).
2-36%, protein content 9.8-18.2%, ash content 0.31-2.23%
and water absorbing capacity from 53.5 – 69.7. Such Problem Statement
information is key in using weighted average quality The onset of the year 2020 was met with wheat
indicators to comply to specific standards for and when shortages in Zimbabwe; nationwide. This in turn resulted in
grading. However, the chief indicator used in grade bread shortages and the unprecedented halts in
determination is whiteness or color acceptability. On the confectionery-based businesses, bakeries and businesses
other hand, some indicators such as ash content are alike (Demaree-Saddler. H., 2020). In response to the
significant in cereals since they control separation of brans imminent starvation; the government called for wheat
from the endosperm in assessing flour quality. substitutes from which sweet potato ranked top of the list
(FEWS NET., 2020). This however was met with reluctance
In another study (Samsher, 2013) where the functional from the public on account of how the tuber is perceived
properties of different flours were assessed between wheat locally. The bulk of Africa consume the tuber traditionally,
flour, rice flour, green gram flour and potato flour. The that is, it is harvested and consumed as is; ‘from the ground
identified functional properties evaluated included swelling to the pot’ (Mmasa. J.J., 2012). The amount of sweet potato
capacity, water absorption capacity, oil absorption capacity, derived products should be well exhausted within the
emulsion activity and stability, foam capacity and stability, national market. Such should be able to cater to many
For treatment 1 after pretreatment the slices were Preparation of Raw Sample
transferred to an oven for thermal treatment, for treatment 2, A mass of 50g from each sample was weighed and
after pretreatment, the slices were transferred to boiling labelled accordingly. They were washed in clean water to
water for 5-10 minutes, then transferred to ice cold water to remove all soil and debris and sliced transversely into 1cm
stop the cooking process. Once cooled the slices were then width slices. The slices were pretreated in a 7% solution of
transferred to the oven for thermal treatment (Fetuga. G. O., Ascorbic acid for a period of 10 minutes after which they
2013). Lastly for treatment 3, after pretreatment the slices were chopped further finely and ground by mortar and pestle
were chopped roughly into flakes and transferred to into a fine paste. These samples were used for pre-process
anaerobic vessels for natural fermentation in 5% salt and 1% analyses.
sucrose concentration at rtp (28-30℃) for 1-3 days
(Yuliana. N., 2020) after which they were rinsed under Preparation of Fermentation Broth Samples
running water and transferred to the oven for thermal For each fermenting sample, the fermentation broth
treatment. For all treatments the slices were dried at 60℃ was extracted at 24hr intervals and stored at 4℃ for use
(Farinu. A., 2007) until a constant mass was achieved and during analysis of fermentation kinetics.
the final mass recorded and the slices ground to fine powder.
The WHC was determined as follows: Evaluation of the Effect of Treatment on Selected
Chemical Properties
KEY procedure was carried out under rtp. A study (Yuliana. N.,
A CHINGOVHA TREAT1 Fresh 2019) was carried out in which natural fermentation in 5%
B DELVIA TREAT 2 Parboiled brine showed potential; both as a preservation technique and
C IRENE TREAT 3 Fermentation in the induction of lactic acid fermentation. Fermentation
D VICTORIA has been rendered ideal in SP with regard to the starch
E NEMANGA content whereas Lactic acid production capabilities have
F ALICIA been identified as well (Pagana. I., 2013). Additionally,
G TSUMAYA saline solutions as that used in fermentation treatment have
been observed to have properties that prevent browning in
Generally ascorbic acid has been identified as an agent selected foods and additional antimicrobial properties.
for retention of carotenoids (Minuye. M., 2021) being heat (Baiano. A., 2003). The best color profiles were observed
sensitive. Studies suggest that the heat sensitive nature of for the fermented products which in turn indicates positive
ascorbic acid in treatment generally makes it non-ideal as a interactions between ascorbic acid pretreatment and saline
pretreatment to be followed by boiling (Mercali. G. D., conditions in fermentation treatment in preventing browning
2014). For this reason, the parboiled dried flakes had an (Baiano. A., 2003). Contrastingly, the color profiles of the
unappealing discoloring outwardly which could be parboiled products could indicate negative interaction
attributed as browning, whilst the interior retained some of between the ascorbic acid pretreatment and the heat
its natural coloring. For this reason; some studies that have treatment.
coupled ascorbic acid as pretreatment to thermal drying
have favored the use of sulfur dioxide and sodium Determination of Emulsification Stability
metabisulfite solutions instead (Shawky. A. S., 2020). The The analysis determined that the flour product had low
fermented products maintained a color profile comparable to emulsification stability. The determined mean was 11.41s
the treatment 1 products due to the fermentation conditions. (to 2d.p) and a median of 11s with the minimum value of
The fermentation procedure used throughout the scope of 6.4s and the maximum value; 17.4s. For all samples,
this study was predetermined to mimic natural spontaneous regardless of treatment and variety phase partitioning was
fermentation, to achieve this, there was no heat input and the observed and the results illustrated as follows:
Fig 2 Effect of Sweet Potato Variety and Post-Harvest Tuber Treatment on Emulsification Stability of Flour Products
Fig 3 Effect of Sweet Potato Variety and Post-Harvest Tuber Treatment on Water Holding Capacity
In any case WHC demonstrates the relationship and sweet potato in turn holds a comparable WHC (Doporto. M.
interaction between protein and water in food systems. The C., 2012). For this; reason, sweet potato holds potential in
protein within the sampled product achieves this by being a chief ingredient in formulating instant porridge.
absorbing, retaining and entrapping water against gravity
and by so doing prevents water from being expelled The p value< 0.05 (Appendix 4: table 11) highlights
(Rakszegi. M., 2014). Towards the development of cereal the significant differences between varieties with respect to
and instant porridge, wetting and hydration as that water holding capacity.
demonstrated through determination of WHC is significant
in demonstrating interactions. For example; rice and maize Determination of OHC.
are the most popular ingredients for gluten free foods, but The OHC of the different flour samples as shown
they tend to exhibit limited technological properties below are expressed in grams per 100g fresh sample. It was
especially with regard to cohesive interactions (Boucheham. determined that the statistical mean was 169.36% (correct to
N., 2019). This in turn highlights that any product intended 2 d.p). The analysis also highlighted that all values attained
to substitute wheat in any cereal-based product should under treatment 2 of parboiling fell below the estimated
exhibit functional properties somewhat comparable or mean value, the same for fermentation treatment except for
consistent with that of wheat. There is a correlation between Tsumaya. In that same light, the minimum value 57.50%
the WHC of a flour and the solvent retention capacity, these was found for parboiled Chingovha variety. Generally, there
combined properties establish the functional profile of the was a significant difference between the OHC for the
flour product (Kweon. M., 2011). Generally, it has been different samples as suggested by the p value (α<0.05):
determined that gluten can absorb liquid water more than 2 Appendix 4; table 12. The attained results are presented as
times its initial weight, the results attained indicate that follows:
Fig 4 Effect of Sweet Potato Variety and Post-Harvest Tuber Treatment on the Oil Holding Capacity
OHC is a measure of the interactive properties the intricate differences and consequences of the treatment
between the samples in question and oil. This has been options).
described as to the amount of oil that a sample can absorb
per unit of weight (Ladjal. E Y., 2015). As such OHC is a Determination of Moisture Content (According to
relevant measure on how well the texture of a product will AOAC Method 1995)
be. The analysis is crucial in that it provides an indication of Generally, SP have a predetermined moisture content
application. Generally, it is expected that boiled flours ought of 62.58 – 64.34 ±0.42% (Vimala. B., 2011). In this
to portray greater oil entrapment capacity compared to the experiment the minimum value for treatment 1, treatment 2
other treatments (Ma. Z., 2011). However, in this and treatment 3 were 62.8% (Alicia: treatment 1), 59.57%
experiment it is exhibited below the statistical mean. This is (Namanga; treatment 2) and 31.98% (Victoria treatment 3),
because OHC is a direct measure on the surface availability whilst the maximum values were 74.7% (Tsumaya;
of hydrophobic amino acids and non-polar chains (Benitez. treatment 1), 88.76% (Tsumaya; treatment 2) and 72.284%
V., 2013). Since the consequence of gelatinization was (Alicia; treatment 3) respectively. The acquired mean value
exhibited for parboiled samples, this affected particle size; for each treatment was 68.99%, 75.94% and 56.69%
flour particles from parboiled treatments were larger after respectively. From these values it is determined that
grinding. On the other hand, OHC for treatment 1 for Namanga and Tsumaya had the moisture content that fell
Chingovha, Delvia, Irene, Victoria and Namanga were above the treatment 1 mean, Delvia and Namanga had the
significantly higher across all treatments. This illustrates the moisture content that fell below the treatment 2 mean and
availability of non-polar chains and hydrophobic amino Victoria and Namanga had the moisture content values that
acids within the raw dried tubers. The differences in OHC fell below the treatment 3 mean. This is shown in Fig 7:
across the different treatments for the same varieties indicate
The protein content in raw SP samples was first based methods exploit extraction procedures prior to
determined. It has been determined that protein in SP is measurement as a means for selective detection. This means
dominantly sporamin A and B, which are subject to increase the spectrophotometry values are only based on the amount
and decrease during sprouting, maturation and storage of substance that has been successfully extracted from the
(Maeshima. M., 1985). However; SP are generally not given sample. The low values observed for parboiled flour
regarded as a rich protein source, (Shireen. K. F., 2001). For may have been a consequence of ineffective protein
this reason, the objective of introducing processing extraction. Studies have shown that particle size has a
techniques should be focused on methods that retain the significant impact on the rate of extraction (Russin. T. A.,
most nutritional composition of the starting product (Lyimo. 2007) (Yuliani. S. H., 2019).
M. E., 2010).
Fermentation on the other hand is typically held in
Generally parboiled flour samples exhibited a regard as a nutritional enhancer (Samtiya. M., 2021). For
significant decline in protein content when compared to the this reason; the protein content in fermented samples was
raw values (with an exception for Victoria and Tsumaya). both expected and observed to be higher than that from the
Throughout the analysis they uniformly maintained a raw samples. This is synonymous in a study carried out in
decline with respect to the analysis. This detail suggests Indonesia that explored improving flour properties by
damage and destruction to the protein constituents as a fermentation (Yuliana. N., 2016). Similarly, fermentation is
consequence of the heat treatment. Generally boiling has favored on SP with respect to the high starch content of the
been identified to have a detrimental impact on protein tubers; (Bach. D., 2021) and introduction of flavors.
(Shehu. D. M., 2018). On that same note; the raw values are
comparable to that for fresh (treatment 1), this suggests that Evaluation of TPC (Folin Ciocalteu Spectrophotometric
the heat input used to dry the raw tubers (treatment 1) was Method)
not extensively aggressive to the point of denaturing The results indicated there was a significant difference
proteins. The rises and declines observed between raw and in the effect of treatment on TPC (p≤0.05; Appendix 4;
treatment 1 can be attributed to the conclusions drawn by table 15). The statistical mean was found to be 0.789 (to 3
Maeshima (Maeshima. M., 1985). On the other hand, the d.p), the maximum value; 1.689 (to 3 dp) was observed for
effect of gelatinization on particle size as observed for the raw Victoria (before processing) whilst the minimum
parboiled samples may have contributed to the low phenolic value was observed for Alicia having undergone
availability of protein for measurement. Spectrophotometry treatment 1. The results are shown as follows:
Generally phenolic content in tubers is subject to impact flavor (Rodriguez. H., 2009). Parboiled flour
factors such as: cultivar, environmental conditions, cultural samples exhibited lower values as compared to the raw
practices, postharvest practices, processing conditions, and samples. The subjection of thermal processing in water
storage (Chandrasekara. A., 2016). For this reason, the results in changes in phenolic composition in that certain
initial TPC in the raw samples vary. Chingovha had the degrees of boiling are associated with phenolic retention
lowest values across all treatments, whilst the orange which can be attributed to higher extractability, rupture of
varieties had amongst the highest values, this supports the polyphenolic complexes and inactivation of polyphenol
evidence that highlight that flesh color as an indicator of oxidase (POD) (Minatel. I. O., 2017). The choice of drying
TPC (Musilova. J., 2017) The decrease of these values method generally induces reduction of phenolic compounds,
across all treatments was typical as expected on account of and brings into account factors such as drying temperature,
their unstable structures and hence easily prone to drying time and air velocity (Miranda. M., 2010). The rate
degradation (Minatel. I. O., 2017). As such the TPC in raw of degradation brings into account other factors such as
samples had the highest values across all treatment and were handling and quality of tubers and type of phenolic acid in
comparable to the values obtained post fermentation question.
(treatment 3). The increase demonstrated under treatment 3
is as a result of the choice of treatment. Fermentation has Evaluation of Β Carotene Content
been identified to demonstrate a marked increase in the TPC It was determined that the mean concentration across
for the product in question (Adetuyi. F. O., 2014). all treatments was 0.017 (to 3 dp) and the maximum and
Fermentation is the favored option with respect to food minimum values; 0.031 and 0.000144 respectively. The
processing in that it increases the bioavailability of phenolic attained results are shown below:
compounds in food and generation of compounds that
Fig 8 Showing Effect of Pre-Thermal Treatment on Sweet Potato Flour Beta Carotene Quantity
Fig 9 Showing Effect of Pre-Thermal Treatment on Sweet Potato Flour Sugar Content
The above results show differences in varieties as such sugars is as a result of maturation and storage. As such
exhibited by initial sugar concentration differences in raw the variability on sugar content has been alluded to be due to
samples. For this reason; F and G (Alicia and Tsumaya had type of cultivar and the effects of harvest time and storage
the highest initial sugar concentrations). This has also been (Adu-Kwarteng. E., 2014). Sweet potato is generally
alluded in other studies that observe the implication of superior as compared to other starches on account of
varietal differences on nutritional composition of different richness in vitamins, minerals and dietary fibre, bioactive
sweet potato varieties (Ingabire. M. R., 2011). Such compounds, whilst possessing a low glycemic index.
differences are key in the determination of product Sweetness in sweet potato is due to presence of endogenous
formulation, development and design (Elmadfa. I., 2010). In sugars present during harvest and the effect of processing
this analysis; total soluble sugar content comprises of treatment (Kays. S. J., 2005). Generally drying
glucose, fructose and sucrose. Naturally accumulation of independently and boiling prior to drying are expected to
Fig 10 Showing Changes in Total Soluble Sugar Content During Fermentation at 24hr Intervals
Generally, sugar is gradually consumed during fermentation which during spectrophotometry can be observed as decrease in
the OD reading. A decline in absorbance value was observed for each variety at 24-hour intervals. For varieties A, B, C and G
there is a peak in the values followed by gradual decline at t=48hrs and t=72hours. Whilst A, C, D, E and G exhibit peaks at the
t=72hour intervals. Similar peaks have been observed in fermentation studies involving both yeast and bacteria. In bacteria the
peak or plateau in concentrations are suggested to be as a result of the utilization and replacement of sugar via microbial
metabolism, whilst a continuous decline would have been observed upon sugar depletion with no replacement (Horvath. B. O.,
2020). The sugar reduction rates are not synonymous on account of the differences in varieties and their independent reaction
kinetics, initial sugar content, concentration of fermenting agents, fermentation conditions and the microbe in question (Sharma.
R., 2020). This was implied with the p-value≤0.05 (Appendix 4; table 18). The color changes were also observed and noted down
as follows:
The data highlights the popularity of the raw tubers within households and limited availability and information of SP
processing or their derived products.100% of the respondents were familiar with the white fleshed SP variety, however the same
could not attributed to the other varieties, especially the purple-fleshed variety; where 1 in the 30 respondents was familiar with
the variety. SP was largely prepared within the respective households at a need-to-eat basis; strictly for consumption in which no
freezing or drying followed after. Although the number of respondents who had come across SP derived products within the
market was low, the number of respondents open to purchasing and potentially replacing wheat and maize competing products
was well into the 90th percentile. This could be alluded as the respondents being open to new products, or the respondents being
exhausted from the current selection on the maize and wheat competing products.
Generally, all respondents exhibited a keen interest in the potential product as all respondents proceeded to be panelists for
the sensory evaluation.
KEY
Par Parboiled
Ferm Fermented
The lowest preferences were observed mostly for the parboiled flour samples with the exception of parboiled Tsumaya
which ranked least awful with respect to both color and smell. Interestingly Tsumaya variety across all treatments had the least
awful ranking. This highlights a fundamental distinction of the raw tuber in that choice of pretreatment option did not have a
severely detrimental effect on the sensory attributes of the flour product.
V. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS fleshed was significantly low. This highlighted the need for
targeted efforts and strategies in raising awareness on the
SP tubers are an essential diet component, the different SP varieties and their health benefits. The study
nutritional diversity and constitution of the tuber makes it has demonstrated strategies towards production of SP flour
ideal for product development in the form of SP derived and in so doing has highlighted areas for optimization.
products. Such products would maintain the health benefits Although fermentation was demonstrated to be the most
of the tuber whilst introducing variety in the form of ideal pretreatment relative to flour quality, effect of
exciting and ready to eat products with the potential to treatment on chemical properties and product acceptability,
compete with mainline crop-based derivatives specifically there is need for standardization of the processing procedure
instant porridge. The questionnaire revealed a lag in the to achieve quality SP flour product prior to formulation into
availability and knowledge of such products while the instant porridge for example in defining fermentative
sensory evaluation demonstrated a keen interest on such pathways. This is expected to result in increased demand for
products. The study showed that thermal processing in SP SP tubers and development of a protocol for post-harvest
flour production could be coupled with pretreatments such tuber handling and storage prior to processing. It is also
as parboiling and fermentation. However, each pretreatment recommended that the parboiling pretreatment be further
choice had varying implications on nutrition loss or improved and optimized to suit variations in SP tuber
retention and general sensory appeal. The number of texture so as to avoid the consequence of gelatinization as
respondents familiar with SP varieties other than the white- opposed to ruling it out completely as a pretreatment option.
A. Appendix 1
B. Appendix 2
Thank you for Agreeing to Answer this Short Questionnaire. Please Answer all Questions by Ticking the Most Appropriate
Response. Tick in the Boxes Provided. all Responses are Strictly Confidential and Anonymous
□ Under 21
□ 22-31 years
□ 32-40 years
□ Over 40
□ Male
□ Female
□ Non binary
□ Ordinary level
□ Advanced level
□ Degree
□ Masters
□ PhD
□ Yes
□ No
□ Indifferent
□ White flesh
□ Yellow flesh
□ Orange flesh
□ Purple flesh
Have you come Across any Sweet Potato Derived Products Currently within your Local Markets, Such Products Include;
Flour, Paste, Beverages, Alcohol, Dried Flakes Etc.
□ Yes
□ No
Have you Tried or Would you be Open to Trying Such Sweet Potato Derived Products?
□ Yes
□ No
If Sweet Potato Derived Products were Available Today, how Likely would you be to Purchase them Instead of Competing
Products Currently Available from Maize and wheat?
□ Extremely likely
□ Very likely
□ Somewhat likely
□ Not so likely
□ Not at all likely
Would you be Interested in being Part of a Sensory Evaluation Panel on the Best Sweet Potato Variety for Flour to be
Incorporated Into an Instant Porridge Formulation?
□ Yes
□ No
C. Appendix 3
KEY 1 2 3 4 5
Awful Bad Moderate Good Great
Comment:………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………
Table 10 One Way ANOVA for the effect of SP variety on Emulsification Stability
ANOVA: Single Factor
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 7 86.9 12.41429 15.33476
Column 2 7 68.2 9.742857 6.682857
Column 3 7 84.5 12.07143 7.949048
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 29.5781 2 14.78905 1.48055 0.253937 3.554557
Within Groups 179.8 18 9.988889
Total 209.3781 20
Total 0.788401 27
Table 6 One Way ANOVA For Determination Of Effect Of Treatment On Beta Carotene Content
ANOVA: Single Factor
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 7 0.163891 0.023413 0.000115
Column 2 7 0.071191 0.01017 3.28E-05
Column 3 7 0.104099 0.014871 5.22E-05
Column 4 7 0.143358 0.02048 0.000101
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 0.000729 3 0.000243 3.233935 0.040021 3.008787
Within Groups 0.001804 24 7.52E-05
Total 0.002534 27
Table 7 One Way ANOVA for Determination of effect of treatment on sugar content in flour
ANOVA: Single Factor
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 7 1.6653 0.2379 0.013702
Column 2 7 1.238 0.176857 0.011678
Column 3 7 1.465 0.209286 0.011419
Column 4 7 0.5223 0.074614 0.000692
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Between Groups 0.106485 3 0.035495 3.787134 0.023482 3.008787
Within Groups 0.224942 24 0.009373
Total 0.331427 27
Table 8 One Way ANOVA for Determination of sugar content in fermentation broth at 24-hour intervals
ANOVA: Single Factor
SUMMARY
Groups Count Sum Average Variance
Column 1 7 4.393 0.627571 0.000504
Column 2 7 4.521 0.645857 0.031729
Column 3 7 2.761 0.394429 0.002752
Column 4 7 3.305 0.472143 0.006256
ANOVA
Source of Variation SS df MS F P-value F crit
Table 9 showing summary of descriptive statistics for sensory evaluation panelist’s responses
A1 A2 A3 A4 A5 B1 B2 B3 B4 B5 C1 C2 C3 C4 C5
Mean 5.809524 5.714286 7.571429 6.428571 4.47619 4.952381 7.285714 5.190476 8.333333 4.238095 0.571429 3.904762 14.09524 6.904762 4.52381
Standard Error
1.382921 1.102255 0.919553 1.520607 1.269831 1.136989 1.625896 0.97497 1.906547 1.5336 0.147542 0.572816 1.453902 1.09741 0.855289
Median 3 6 7 2 1 4 6 4 6 1 0 4 15 6 3
Mode 0 0 6 2 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 6 10 6 1
Standard Deviation
6.337342 5.051167 4.213923 6.968296 5.819098 5.210338 7.450791 4.467875 8.736895 7.027836 0.676123 2.624972 6.662618 5.028964 3.919427
Sample Variance
40.1619 25.51429 17.75714 48.55714 33.8619 27.14762 55.51429 19.9619 76.33333 49.39048 0.457143 6.890476 44.39048 25.29048 15.3619
Kurtosis 0.200723 0.140175 0.022741 -0.2315 -0.61076 0.821084 0.279163 0.146419 -0.40052 3.002594 -0.35019 -0.96083 -0.81555 0.872945 1.830545
Skewness 0.993821 0.751215 0.690734 1.074153 1.124148 1.265293 0.975842 1.006106 0.911132 2.09698 0.788162 0.132579 -0.18044 0.901407 1.431081
Range 21 17 16 20 15 18 25 15 28 23 2 9 23 20 14
Minimum 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 1
Maximum 21 17 17 20 15 18 25 15 28 23 2 9 25 20 15
Sum 122 120 159 135 94 104 153 109 175 89 12 82 296 145 95
Count 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21
Largest(1) 21 17 17 20 15 18 25 15 28 23 2 9 25 20 15
Smallest(1) 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 1
Confidence Level(95.0%)
2.884724 2.299264 1.918155 3.17193 2.648822 2.371717 3.391559 2.033752 3.976987 3.199033 0.307768 1.194873 3.032787 2.289157 1.784102
Key
A Awful
B Bad
C Moderate
D Good
E Great
1 Color
2 Texture
3 Smell
All statical analysis used throughout this study were carried out and exported from Microsoft excel.